Twisted Sister — Come Out And Play: Twisted Sister's Overreach After the Fire

Twisted Sister's Overreach After the Fire — the Vault Deep Dive on Twisted Sister — Come Out And Play (1985).

The Story

By 1985 Twisted Sister had ridden "Stay Hungry" to platinum heights, and the world seemed to want more of the same. Instead the band chased ambition. Dee Snider, the group's sole songwriter, wrote an album meant to prove they were more than a novelty of face paint and defiance. Expectations were enormous and the follow-up carried the weight of a runaway hit behind it. The title itself was a dare, a challenge thrown at anyone who doubted them. But the cultural moment had shifted fast, and an album built to consolidate a throne instead became the record where the momentum quietly slipped.

The Sound

This is Twisted Sister reaching for scale. The guitars of Jay Jay French and Eddie Ojeda are bigger and glossier, the arrangements busier, the production thicker than the raw stomp fans first loved. Dee Snider's voice is still the anchor, part street preacher and part cartoon villain, selling every chorus with total conviction. There are anthems built for arenas and a few genuine curveballs where the band experiments with tempo and texture. The heaviness is polished rather than dangerous, which was the point and also the risk. It sounds expensive and confident, a band betting that bigger meant better in the mid-eighties.

The Sessions

Dieter Dierks, best known for his long run shaping the Scorpions, produced the record, and his fingerprints are all over its layered, radio-ready sheen. The sessions leaned on studio craft, stacking guitars and vocals for maximum punch, a deliberate step up in gloss from the band's earlier work. A guest spot from actor Alice Cooper and a memorable comedic cameo appearance added color to the project's promotion. The playing is tight and drilled, the sound of a band and producer chasing a specific commercial target. Every element was polished, arranged and refined toward the arena, with little of the earlier grit left untouched.

The Legacy

"Come Out And Play" is the hinge point in the Twisted Sister story, the moment the wave crested and began to recede. Its lead single climbed and MTV played the videos, but it never matched the cultural saturation of the album before it. Fans and history remember it as the ambitious, slightly overreaching record, the one where the band tried to grow beyond the persona that made them famous. That very reach makes it fascinating to revisit now. It captures a specific mid-eighties confidence, a band swinging for the biggest possible prize, and it stands as an honest document of ambition meeting a shifting market.

What the pressing tells us

The part most listings skip. This is how we grade and how you can tell copies apart:

• West German Target-era CD on Atlantic, an early-generation import pressing.
• Matrix reads 7567 81275-2 2895 979 01, aiding edition identification.
• Marked as an Import edition, pressed in Germany for wider distribution.
• Target-era German CDs are prized by collectors for early manufacturing quality.

Session file

• Produced by Dieter Dierks, famed for his work with Scorpions.
• Released in 1985 on Atlantic Records.
• Dee Snider wrote all the album's material.
• Layered guitar and vocal stacking gave it a glossy sheen.
• Guest appearances added promotional color to the project.

Who played on it

• Dee Snider — Lead vocals, songwriter
• Jay Jay French — Guitar
• Eddie Ojeda — Guitar
• Mark Mendoza — Bass
• A.J. Pero — Drums

Vault Trivia

1. Which producer helmed "Come Out And Play" in 1985?

1. Tom Werman
2. Dieter Dierks
3. Martin Birch
4. Eddie Kramer

Reveal the answer

Dieter Dierks — Dieter Dierks, the Scorpions' longtime producer, brought his layered German studio polish.

2. Which actor guested on the album during its 1985 sessions?

1. Vincent Price
2. Alice Cooper
3. Ozzy Osbourne
4. Meat Loaf

Reveal the answer

Alice Cooper — Alice Cooper contributed a guest appearance to the ambitious follow-up record.

3. What album immediately preceded this one in the band's catalog?

1. Under The Blade
2. Stay Hungry
3. You Can't Stop Rock 'n' Roll
4. Love Is For Suckers

Reveal the answer

Stay Hungry — 1984's "Stay Hungry" was the platinum breakthrough this record had to follow.

4. Which drummer played on the 1985 sessions?

1. A.J. Pero
2. Joey Franco
3. Tommy Aldridge
4. Carmine Appice

Reveal the answer

A.J. Pero — A.J. Pero drummed here; Joey Franco joined the band later in the decade.

5. Which country pressed the collectible Target-era CD featured here?

1. Japan
2. United States
3. West Germany
4. France

Reveal the answer

West Germany — West German Target-era plants produced many early, sought-after compact discs.

Come down to the vault and hear the ambition for yourself.

Rare Collectibles Chicago grades and photographs every copy in-house — 20 years, 25,000+ sales. Browse the vault.